
Home > Women >
Inspiring
Women > TCW
Cover Stories

Today's Christian Woman, November/December 2000
Survivor's Story Christian singer Bonnie Keen endured divorce,
depression, a near date rape, and the destruction of her
career. So why's she able to smile? By Camerin Courtney
Considering all Christian singer Bonnie
Keen's been through, you'd expect her to be a bitter, angry
woman.
Her first husband's relationship with
another woman led to the demise of their 10-year marriage 10
years ago. As a single mom to two young children—Courtney,
then six, and Graham, then two—Bonnie endured constant
financial struggles and nearly had to move her fractured
family in with her parents. When she finally re-entered the
dating scene, she narrowly escaped being date-raped by a "nice
Christian man."
Just when it appeared things were finally
looking up and First Call, the multiple Grammy-nominated and
Dove Award-winning Christian singing group she'd been part of
for 10 years, was about to sign its biggest recording deal to
date, infidelity struck again. This time it was in the form of
the highly publicized affair in 1994 between her married
groupmate MaraBeth Jordan and Christian solo artist Michael
English, also married. The record deal was lost and the
Christian music industry turned its back on First Call as
everyone tried to figure out how to respond to this
unprecedented scandal.
Her livelihood deeply damaged and her
personal life in shambles, Bonnie sank into deep depression.
Unable to eat, sleep, or stop crying, she ignored thoughts of
suicide merely for the sake of her children.
Yet today Bonnie, 45, sits in a trendy
pizza joint in a Nashville suburb not far from the home she
now shares with her second husband, Brent, looking, oddly
enough, happy. In fact, one of the first things you notice
about Bonnie—besides her 5'11" stature!—is her effervescent
personality. She's released a solo album, Marked for Life
(Spring Hill), and a book, Blessed Are the Desperate
for They Will Find Hope (Harvest House), to encourage
others.
So what happened?
In this exclusive TCW interview, Bonnie
tells of the surprising companion she found in her darkest
hours, explains why she calls herself an "out-of-the-closet
basket case," and reveals her secrets to survival, hope, and
joy. How did you find out that your
ex-husband had fallen in love with someone
else? Through some of our
friends. He'd actually told them he was in love with a woman
he'd met at work.
But I have to be honest, things weren't
perfect before that discovery. Although outwardly we seemed
like the perfect couple, behind the scenes, Daniel and I had
awful arguments about everything from finances to our physical
relationship. Our endless discussions got us nowhere, so I
dragged us into counseling, hoping for healing. Did counseling help? Our therapist helped us face negative patterns
that had existed from the beginning of our marriage. For
example, I'm the classic firstborn overachiever. I grew up
thinking the wife took care of everything, from the bills to
the kids, and I thrived on that role. And Daniel grew up with
a mom who divorced three times, so he wanted a stable woman in
his life, someone to take care of him. Our personalities fit
nicely with each other—but it wasn't a healthy
fit.
In what
way? While Daniel liked being
taken care of, I believe over time he became threatened by it.
He never had a chance to feel like the strong one. We didn't
have a relationship of equals.
Through counseling, I realized I needed to
stop playing the parent role in our marriage. While I tried to
back off, it was difficult to undo patterns we'd been living
in for a decade. It required a tremendous amount of work.
That's why I think this other relationship was so tempting to
Daniel; it didn't come with any baggage. How did you respond to the fact that he'd fallen
in love with someone else? I
confronted Daniel, but at first he wouldn't admit it. My
friends confirmed it was true, and I finally got him to talk
about the other relationship in counseling. We went through a
gut-wrenching year and a half of talking, counseling, trying
everything I could think of to make our marriage
work.
But we didn't make much progress and my
health rapidly deteriorated. I lost a ton of weight and
underwent two surgeries for precancerous conditions. After so
much time and so many health problems, my father said to me,
"You've done everything you can. I want you to call a lawyer
and get on with your life." A couple other close Christian
friends and my pastor told me the same thing, and it was clear
that Daniel wanted to be with another woman.
Sensing a peace about my decision, I filed
for divorce. How did others respond to
the divorce? Most people didn't
have all the facts. Since I was the one initiating it, the
consensus was that I'd flipped out. Everyone but our closest
friends who knew the whole story felt I was the
"villian."
I wanted to pass out flyers saying, "I know
I'm no picnic to live with sometimes, but you don't know all
the details." People who didn't know me or the circumstances
wrote me scathing letters.
I was already beating myself up over the
whole thing. I felt as though I'd failed God, my parents, my
friends, my ex-husband, my children. Even though I had
biblical grounds and felt God's release to go ahead with the
divorce, I felt so ashamed that I'd failed in the primary
relationship in my life. What did you
do with all that guilt? When my
marriage fell apart, I finally had to face all the negative
emotions I'd ignored for years. That was overwhelming! But it
also forced me to start questioning all I'd been taught as a
kid. I began to search what God's Word says about our
emotions. I discovered that Jesus got angry and sad and hurt.
And if he felt these emotions, then it must be okay for me as
well.
I also realized that when Christ was on the
earth, he didn't seek out perfect people. When I realized
Christ really liked basket-case women, I found peace. And I
found the freedom to be imperfect.
I finally got it: We aren't saved or loved
because of our achievements, but because of Christ's death on
the cross. I discovered what an amazing gift grace
is. How did your kids handle the
divorce? They were so
young—Courtney was six and Graham was two—that I'm not sure
they totally understood.
Graham doesn't really have any memories of us
living together as a family, and that bothers him. Lately he's
been asking, "Did you and Dad ever have fun together?" I'll
answer, "Oh, yeah. Let me tell you about the time we did this
…" Graham needs to know it wasn't always bad. And he needs his
dad to be a hero. So I try to honor the positive times—for my
kids' sake and for mine. There are good memories. And though
it's painful to remember them, I need to.
It's been an act of discipline for me to
speak positively to my children about their father. They've
been hurt enough; they don't need to hear my pain, too.
The one thing I really wanted to do for them
was keep the house. We lived in a sweet neighborhood with
great Christian neighbors and a bunch of kids who ran in packs
together from yard to yard. I didn't want to tear them away
from that, too; I wanted something to remain stable. Wasn't that a challenge
financially? You bet. In our
state, the law requires divorced couples to divide the equity
in your house, regardless of the circumstances. So I decided
to pay Daniel back every month a piece of equity from the
house until it was paid off. I wasn't earning much performing
with First Call, singing advertising jingles, and being a
backup vocalist on other people's albums, so it took forever.
I'd wake up in the middle of the night worrying about how I
was going to buy groceries.
Several times we almost had to sell the
house, but God always provided something at the 11th hour. A
friend would offer to pay for a year of my kids' schooling, or
a check would arrive just in the nick of time. Sometimes we
lived on credit cards.
But in the end, the children never had to
leave the house in which they grew up. It was a safe haven
during some awful times. Have you been
able to forgive your ex-husband? Yes, but it didn't happen overnight. Sometimes
all I could say was, I'm willing to forgive at some point,
but I'm not there now. God used that willingness.
The reality is, there are two people involved
in a divorce, two sides to every story. I needed forgiveness
as much as Daniel did. Sure, technically his relationship with
another woman split us up, but I wasn't perfect either. When I
realized how much God has forgiven me, I couldn't help but
believe that forgiveness was my door to peace. What about "the other woman"? Two years after we divorced, Daniel married her.
That was extremely hard. Nothing prepares you for seeing your
ex-spouse marry again. He was moving on with his life, and I
was alone, struggling with single parenting.
But knowing the kids were watching me for
cues as to how to respond to their father—and now their
stepmother—was good. I realized I could teach them a huge
lesson about bitterness or forgiveness. And I don't want
bitter kids. How have you modeled
forgiveness? Here's an example:
When Courtney turned 16, her father and I and our spouses took
her to dinner together. We gave her a purity ring and prayed
for her to honor God with her body and her
life.
Wasn't that awkward
with all of you together? Yes,
but you learn to deal with it. This definitely couldn't have
happened five years ago. God hates divorce, and this
awkwardness is part of the reason why. A 16th birthday should
be joyful, not awkward. But I've learned time and again that
God can redeem anything if we allow him to.
I've established a friendship with my
ex-husband's wife. It took me years to get to that point.
She's been a great step-mom to my kids, and now she and I get
along great. But there were several years of silent agony.
At some point I realized we're all going to
be in heaven together. The Bible says if you believe in Christ
and repent of your sins, which I believe they've done, then
there's grace. So I figured we'd better learn to deal with
this relationship here. How long did
you wait to venture back into the dating
scene? Soon after my divorce, I
asked God, "If that was a wrong guy for me, where's the right
one?" There was no answer to that question for several years,
and I wrestled with loneliness and fear.
But four years after the divorce, I met a man
at my children's Christian school. He was a single parent with
two kids near my children's ages, and was on the coaching
team. I'd see him at the kids' games. As I watched how he
helped the kids, I thought he was a nice man. We talked for
more than six weeks before we actually went out. A date!
Well, yes and no. I wanted to meet him at a
restaurant, but he insisted on picking me up. But we never
made it to dinner because he physically attacked me in my
home. He was larger than I am, and I struggled to get
away.
After what seemed like an eternity of heated
conversation and physical struggle, I finally said, "Isn't
this what a lawyer would call attempted date rape?" And then
he left. I was bruised and sore from our struggles. But much
wiser. In what way? I learned how susceptible we are when we're
lonely. When we so desperately want someone to love us, we're
even more of a target. Apparently this guy had hit on a lot of
single moms in the area. I warned several friends and alerted
the school.
It also made me realize I'd made finding a
new husband more important than my relationship with God. I
needed to die to those desires and trust God with my future,
no matter what. Even if I never remarried, I knew I still
needed to be able to find joy in every day. What was happening with First Call at this
point? We were recording and
touring. Marty McCall and MaraBeth Jordan, the other two
people in First Call, were like family to me. They offered me
support and stability during the divorce.
But when we went on a tour with Michael
English, Michael and Mara-Beth seemed to spend a lot of time
together, and their interactions seemed inappropriate for
people who were married—and not to each other. When I saw this
flirtatious behavior while we were on the road, it really
bothered me. I knew what had happened in my own marriage must
have started out the same way. I didn't want them to go
through what I had, so I confronted Michael and
MaraBeth. How did they
respond? They were both very
angry with me. Because I'd verbalized my concern, I became the
bad guy.
That troubled me, because I knew this wasn't
what First Call was all about. Their relationship seemed
suspicious, yet we were scheduled to remain on the road with
Michael for many more months. After wrestling, praying, and
talking with Marty about it, I decided I needed to leave the
group.
The night I was going to tell everyone I was
leaving First Call, MaraBeth finally confessed the affair to
the group. MaraBeth ended up leaving, and I stayed. We
temporarily replaced her with the girl I was going to suggest
to take my place. How did others
respond to the affair? It was
awful. Nothing like this had ever happened in the Christian
music industry, and nobody knew how to respond. We were all in
shock.
A lot of people cancelled our concerts. Marty
and I had to write letters to pastors assuring them we still
loved God. Our concert booking agency didn't call us for
months. A few close friends called us, and Warner Alliance
offered First Call the opportunity to record two albums as a
duo. But the rest of the Christian music industry disappeared
for us. That must have been
horrible. Because our group was
like family, it felt too similar to the mess of my divorce. My
life was ripping apart again. I'd thought this ministry was a
safe place where nothing like that could happen.
I sank into a deep depression. It started
with crying spurts. The next thing I knew, I couldn't stop
crying—at home, in my car, the grocery store.
By the time I went on the Young Messiah Tour
that year, I was crying constantly, barely sleeping two hours
at a time, unable to eat. Most days I wanted to die.
When that tour ended, I got off the bus,
drove home to touch base with the kids, then drove straight to
my pastor's office. I was shaking and weeping so badly that he
called a medical doctor and made an appointment for me that
day.
They wanted to hospitalize me, but I told
them I couldn't. I had two little kids at home who'd already
been through so much. I was their world. They couldn't "lose"
me too, even temporarily. So what did
you do? Immediately the doctor
put me on antidepressants. I reacted badly to the first two we
tried, but by the third I was finally able to sleep for at
least three hours at a time.
Slowly my body stabilized. I'd lost weight,
my metabolism was messed up, I was severely sleep-deprived.
And those were just the physical symptoms! Healing took a long
time. Were you hesitant to go on
medication? Thankfully, my
pastor and my physician, who's also a Christian, had the
wisdom to tell me this had nothing to do with my faith. While
God can heal anything, I needed to treat this medically. My
physician compared my depression to diabetes or pneumonia. If
you have those illnesses, of course you get treatment.
But I'll admit there was a bit of a mental
adjustment. I had to get past the thought that Christians are
supposed to be happy, that depression is just a sign of weak
faith. How did you change that faulty
thinking? To be honest, at first
I got angry with God. I'd been through the divorce, single
parenting, financial struggles, a near date rape, the
destruction of my career, and now depression! I remember lying
on the floor with my Bible across me, weeping and telling God,
"I'm beginning to doubt you're there because I can't see you
anywhere. You're making my life worse." I'd never blamed God
for anything, but I'd finally reached a breaking point.
I lashed out at God and said, "You know what?
I'm sick of this. I'm either going to go deeper with you than
I ever have, or I'm just turning away for good." So I tried
not to believe. I thought maybe I needed to let my
faith go. It hadn't worked in my marriage, ministry, finances,
or physical health. It didn't seem to work anywhere. Did God respond? An amazing thing happened. In the depth of my
despair, I realized the only one who truly understood my pain
was God. I couldn't even verbalize the depth of the emotions
churning inside me. But Bible stories kept coming to my mind.
Horrible stories of death, destruction, and despair. And I was
struck that God didn't leave out the parts of the Bible that
are ugly or depressing. I suddenly related to those stories
and clung to the fact that God had been there in each
one.
I remembered that Isaiah 53:3 says Jesus was
a man of sorrow familiar with suffering. And that he hung out
with people who had messy lives. He loved them and seemed to
say, You're kind of a mess here, but I love you. I want you
to change some things in your life, but most of all I want you
to hold onto me. Let me take this cross and help you bear
it. I finally learned the deep significance of him
carrying our pain and shame and sin.
So I realized God was in this awful abyss
with me. He wasn't afraid of my despair or repulsed by it; he
wanted to take it for me. That was such a powerful,
perspective-changing truth. Sounds like
some much-needed hope. Yes. And
at the same time I was making these realizations, my body was
stabilizing. It took me about a year to get back to normal.
The medication took the edge off the utter despair and
hopelessness in which I'd been trapped. With a rested body and
clearer thinking, I was finally on my way to healing. As I
grew stronger, so did my desire to reach out to many others
who'd been through similar struggles.
I began to see many comrades sitting in the
pews at church, people who were desperate for somebody to
speak about divorce and depression. They felt like the lowest
of the low, afraid the church didn't love them anymore, that
God didn't love them anymore. How have
you helped these hurting people? At the few concerts First Call did perform and
at some of my own, I shared from the stage about my depression
and my near date rape experience.
The first time I shared some of these
stories, the room got deathly quiet. Inside I was thinking,
You shouldn't have shared; they don't want to hear
this. But I plunged ahead. After the concert, several
women came up to me in tears, thanking me profusely for
talking about such tough topics. They were so relieved they
weren't the only Christians who'd been sexually assaulted or
who understood the pain of betrayal. Right then I realized God
could use my experiences to comfort others. And I was amazed
all over again at how he can redeem any situation.
Since then I've started speaking at
conferences for women and single parents. Also, though I'm
still part of First Call, which is now a duo, I recorded a
solo album full of the hope and healing I've found. And I
wrote a book about all I've been through. What do you tell divorced
people? First and foremost, God
truly loves and cares for you. Divorced people so desperately
need to hear that.
No matter how lonely you are, keep your
standards high, especially if you have children watching. Be
careful how quickly you get involved in another romantic
relationship. It's too easy to be relationally needy, which
doesn't make for the best decisions.
Feel all the anger and shame and guilt inside
you. Don't try to deny those negative feelings because they're
part of the healing process. You can't really move forward
until you push through those emotions, not around them.
But at some point if you're willing to forgive and seek
forgiveness, God can bring incredible grace, healing, and
peace to your life.
Find a church that will support you. God
hates divorce, but he doesn't hate divorced people.
Finally, don't give up your dreams, because
many of us think everything's lost. But I've learned firsthand
that nothing's ever wasted if you give it to God. He's
redeemed every broken place in my life. Sometimes it's taken a
while to see his hand. But his redeeming power keeps me
going. You obviously have a heart for
divorced people. When I heard
that the divorce rate is the same in the church as outside it,
I was overwhelmed. That means half the adults sitting in the
pews on Sunday have been affected by divorce.
After I started healing from my depression, I
thought God was going to keep me single so I could minister to
single parents. I wanted to challenge churches to offer
encouragement and practical help to these hurting people. And
then I started seeing Brent … How did
you meet? He's a recording
engineer I've worked with off and on over the past 20 years.
I'd always admired his integrity, faith, and sense of
humor.
Brent had a gut-wrenching divorce, too. His
wife left him and took their five-year-old son with her. Then
she revealed he wasn't really Brent's son after all; he was
another man's child. Brent was devastated. You guys had a lot of pain in
common. Yes, unfortunately. When
he was going through all this years ago, I asked God to bring
him a wife who'd give him children to replace the son he'd had
taken away. I had no idea I was praying myself into his
life!
We ran into each other again after our
divorces and started seeing each other. On our first date he
said, "I re-member what you were wearing the first time I saw
you 20 years ago." He described where I was performing and
everything I had on, down to the boots. He was right! I was
impressed. And here you are 20 years
later. Everyone loved him—my
friends, my family. He knew all about my depression, and
wanted to be with me anyway. My kids took to him, too.
I knew he was a man I could honor and trust.
He makes me laugh and he's so godly. When did you get married? Almost three years ago now. The pastor who'd
counseled me through my divorce and depression, and Brent
through his divorce and the loss of his son, was the one who
married us. We also sought counseling together before the
wedding—just us and with the kids. Brent and I both want this
marriage to be right.
What
are you doing differently in this marriage? I used to think if something bothered me, I
could just take care of it and be strong. But if something
bothers me now, I bring it up. And I'm married to a man who
isn't afraid of that. We know how to talk things
through.
We also have set times of communication.
Brent calls them our "hour of power." Every Sunday we check in
with each other to see how we're doing and to discuss anything
that may be wrong. That's been a great tool for keeping the
lines of communication open.
I often remind myself to back off. I want to
respect Brent in ways I probably disrespected my first husband
by taking over. It sounds as though
you've finally found peace in your
relationships. Yes. When we were
dating, Brent told me that if God would allow us to get
married, it would be like Job, from the Old Testament, who had
restored to him 10 times over what he'd lost.
I look at my life now—the peace I feel with
my first husband and his wife, my healthy kids and wonderful
new mate, my solo album and book to en-courage hurting people
in the church—and I couldn't agree more.
Copyright © 2000 by the author or Christianity
Today, Inc./Today's Christian Woman magazine. Click
here for reprint information on Today's Christian
Woman. November/December
2000, Vol. 22, No. 6, Page
42
Today's Christian Woman Your
Faith | Your
Relationships | Your
Life Inspiring
Women | Your
Funnybone | Your
Neighborhood Home |
Archives |
Contact Us
SUBSCRIBE!
Sign-up today for a risk-free
trial issue
Give Today's Christian Woman
as a gift Buy
1 gift subscription, get 1 FREE!
|
 |
 |